All reports
hanamikoji_displayed reports
#86869: "more than 3 rounds"
notabug: This is not a bug
1
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
a game should only last 3 rounds (on maximum). winner then would be the player with more points• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
my game lasted 4 rounds• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v111
Report history
21. Apr 2023 16:54 • ufm • This bug is a duplicate from another bug:
Duplicate of boardgamearena.com/bug?id=85515
23. May 2023 16:35 • Broxi4769 • This bug is a duplicate from another bug:
I had this 2 times already.
If after the 3rd round, nobody won with 11 points or winning 4 girls, the game continues, specially if points are 8:9 something like this.
So the rule is, that the person with 9 points is the winner (more than 8), but the game continues until one has 4 girls or 11 points. This is wrong. The game always ends after 3 rounds.
If after the 3rd round, nobody won with 11 points or winning 4 girls, the game continues, specially if points are 8:9 something like this.
So the rule is, that the person with 9 points is the winner (more than 8), but the game continues until one has 4 girls or 11 points. This is wrong. The game always ends after 3 rounds.
30. May 2023 2:51 • username314 • This bug is a duplicate from another bug:
as I know, that is optional. before starting playerscan choice if mostly 3 rounds
30. May 2023 4:35 • ufm • This is not a bug:
Again, I cannot find such tiebreakers in the rulebook from EmperorS4 homepage:
drive.google.com/file/d/0B-UUhGhkNzLsdTBYX1U5a25xWjg/view?resourcekey=0-NShuowDi1-Upj_VOu7wUQA
This implementation is following EmperorS4 rules according to the license agreement.
drive.google.com/file/d/0B-UUhGhkNzLsdTBYX1U5a25xWjg/view?resourcekey=0-NShuowDi1-Upj_VOu7wUQA
This implementation is following EmperorS4 rules according to the license agreement.
30. May 2023 8:48 • Broxi4769 • This is not a bug:
Hi UFM,
okay, with the given rule book, I agree that there it is not stated that after 3 rounds there is an end.
I have an older version of the game, where it is clearly stated.
So I agree, as you need to build the game according to the actual rules...then its no error.
However...a game can last then forever... I played for over 6 rounds with no winner... and we both agreed to cancel the game...as we both knew the rule, that after 3 rounds there is a finish.
A lot of players will not like the game this way, as they learned it differently. Maybe you can ask the publisher if they might made a mistake?
There is some discussion on this topic on BGG:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2181503/rules-differences-regarding-endless-play-tie-break
but with no real result....
okay, with the given rule book, I agree that there it is not stated that after 3 rounds there is an end.
I have an older version of the game, where it is clearly stated.
So I agree, as you need to build the game according to the actual rules...then its no error.
However...a game can last then forever... I played for over 6 rounds with no winner... and we both agreed to cancel the game...as we both knew the rule, that after 3 rounds there is a finish.
A lot of players will not like the game this way, as they learned it differently. Maybe you can ask the publisher if they might made a mistake?
There is some discussion on this topic on BGG:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2181503/rules-differences-regarding-endless-play-tie-break
but with no real result....
30. May 2023 10:42 • ufm • This is not a bug:
I have no qualms about the rules.
If you want something to be changed, you should contact them.
If you want something to be changed, you should contact them.
26. Nov 2023 6:45 • Stroegli • This is not a bug:
Hi Emma,
First of all thanks a lot for your reply.
BUT: "Broxi4769" is absolutely right with his points - the rule you show with the link is not an "official" one from the game if you buy it - AND: he is also right that a game can last then forever.
Hanamikoji is soooo nice also it is strictly limited in time with 2 rounds.
So again I would kindly ask if you might overthink this and implement this restriction.
Best and kind regards!
First of all thanks a lot for your reply.
BUT: "Broxi4769" is absolutely right with his points - the rule you show with the link is not an "official" one from the game if you buy it - AND: he is also right that a game can last then forever.
Hanamikoji is soooo nice also it is strictly limited in time with 2 rounds.
So again I would kindly ask if you might overthink this and implement this restriction.
Best and kind regards!
26. Nov 2023 9:17 • ufm • This is not a bug:
This IS official as the linked rule is provided by the publisher directly.
12. May 2024 3:24 • bryancarol07 • This is not a bug:
The official rules say than if there's no winner after the round 3 then the game end. The winner will be the one with the more poins and if there's a drawn again then there is no winner. We should implement an option to play either as many round as we want + another option with the real rules saying than we stop after 3 round
You can see the rules talking about the end of the games in Page 11
FRENCH RULES
iello.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Hanamikoji_rulebook_FR_V1-Light.pdf
Si, après 3 manches, aucun joueur n’a encore rempli de condition de victoire, le gagnant est le joueur avec le plus de points Art. S’il y a égalité, la partie se termine, et il n’y a pas de gagnant
GERMAN RULES
fragkosmos.zendesk.com/hc/de/article_attachments/13286328977948
Falls nach 3 Runden noch immer kein Spieler die Siegbedingung erfüllt hat, gewinnt der Spieler mit mehr Gunstpunkten. Bei Gleichstand endet das Spiel unentschieden.
ENGLISH TRADUCTION
If, after 3 rounds, no player has yet met the victory condition, the winner is the player with the most points Art. If there is a tie, the game ends, and there is no winner
You can see the rules talking about the end of the games in Page 11
FRENCH RULES
iello.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Hanamikoji_rulebook_FR_V1-Light.pdf
Si, après 3 manches, aucun joueur n’a encore rempli de condition de victoire, le gagnant est le joueur avec le plus de points Art. S’il y a égalité, la partie se termine, et il n’y a pas de gagnant
GERMAN RULES
fragkosmos.zendesk.com/hc/de/article_attachments/13286328977948
Falls nach 3 Runden noch immer kein Spieler die Siegbedingung erfüllt hat, gewinnt der Spieler mit mehr Gunstpunkten. Bei Gleichstand endet das Spiel unentschieden.
ENGLISH TRADUCTION
If, after 3 rounds, no player has yet met the victory condition, the winner is the player with the most points Art. If there is a tie, the game ends, and there is no winner
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
