All reports
rollforthegalaxy_displayed reports
#9028: "The card stack counts for other players are often wrong."
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Display bug: some game information displayed was wrong (with no important consequence on the game)
Detailed description
• Please describe the display issue. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
i.imgur.com/5WAci0f.png
I saw that this bug is "fixed", but I have seen it since, almost every game. So either the new code is not live, or the bug is not fixed.• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v63
Report history
19. Jan 2018 0:21 • tufflax • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
This bug appears every game, as far as I know. It is very common.
10. May 2018 11:35 • PastorPew • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Often accompanied by not being able to see the top card on other player's stacks...
14. May 2018 15:49 • drstuey • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
+1 still see this almost every game, really affects decision making.
24. Jun 2018 11:03 • foodbirdlyk • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table #41476956
Move #41
It appears so often and F5 usually solve the problem but it is annoying.
Move #41
It appears so often and F5 usually solve the problem but it is annoying.
3. Aug 2018 20:31 • RegisBull • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Just to report that I also see that, too often. And pressing "Refresh" mixes the order of the tiles already played ...
2. Sep 2018 15:26 • weather3003 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
The bug seems to occur when other people abandon tiles from one stack to select files from the other stack.
23. Jan 2019 13:42 • Biking Gamer • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Still seeing this display bug too.
13. Aug 2019 16:37 • Marphod • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Still happening. I have a screenshot (where one of the stacks is "-7") but forgot to records the game number. I'll try to get one with a game table number too.
17. Apr 2020 1:13 • HedgieWedgie • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
We have more information on this bug:
The bug happens ONLY in your opponent's stack counts. It never happens in yours. Reloading the page will fix the counts. To reproduce this bug, you need to abandon tiles in the development stack and then see what it looks like on another user's screen.
The bug seems to only happen when the other person abandons cards in the development stack. The cards are being decremented on other players' view of the Settlement stack, (but not all of the abandoned development cards decrement from the settlement number, just some).
Two different examples.
Turn A: Peter Mille abandoned development cards and then scouted again.
Peter Mille sees:
imgur.com/LQMfFoi
His opponent sees:
imgur.com/xTIDbNC
Turn B: Peter Mille abandoned development cards.
Peter Mille sees:
imgur.com/7UeYA7m
His opponent sees:
imgur.com/OEwqIH5
(Note that the opponent sees a blank card in the development space as well despite Peter MIlle having a card there.)
The bug happens ONLY in your opponent's stack counts. It never happens in yours. Reloading the page will fix the counts. To reproduce this bug, you need to abandon tiles in the development stack and then see what it looks like on another user's screen.
The bug seems to only happen when the other person abandons cards in the development stack. The cards are being decremented on other players' view of the Settlement stack, (but not all of the abandoned development cards decrement from the settlement number, just some).
Two different examples.
Turn A: Peter Mille abandoned development cards and then scouted again.
Peter Mille sees:
imgur.com/LQMfFoi
His opponent sees:
imgur.com/xTIDbNC
Turn B: Peter Mille abandoned development cards.
Peter Mille sees:
imgur.com/7UeYA7m
His opponent sees:
imgur.com/OEwqIH5
(Note that the opponent sees a blank card in the development space as well despite Peter MIlle having a card there.)
17. Apr 2020 1:21 • HedgieWedgie • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Two other things:
1. The sum of the two numbers seems to equal the total number of cards even if each number is incorrect.
2. The incorrect decrementing appears to be cumulative throughout the game:
imgur.com/il0pUax
1. The sum of the two numbers seems to equal the total number of cards even if each number is incorrect.
2. The incorrect decrementing appears to be cumulative throughout the game:
imgur.com/il0pUax
20. Apr 2020 13:07 • Raptang • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Hi,
I had the same bug today.
Table 77021675
imgur.com/a/xd25F0E
Please fix it. It seems to be discarding tiles that causes the default.
I had the same bug today.
Table 77021675
imgur.com/a/xd25F0E
Please fix it. It seems to be discarding tiles that causes the default.
12. May 2020 6:09 • Timeroler • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
often while playing it will show that the in construction areas of other players are empty. when they are not.
9. Oct 2020 0:47 • SudburyGamer • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I get this issue in every game. Frequently see negative card numbers. Annoying to have to refresh to get accurate numbers, especially in a real time game.
25. Oct 2020 4:56 • Karlsen • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I saw it a lot yesterday on Firefox. I could see cubes appearing on my opponents empty stack. When I left the table and came back it was correct, but soon went wrong again.
23. Nov 2020 18:37 • amber_missy • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
24. Jan 2021 1:15 • matgz • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
My oppenent had 13 developments and -8 worlds. Yeah, right :)
F5 did the trick
F5 did the trick
25. Apr 2021 3:11 • ImpossibleMotion • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Game #167075065, using Firefox 87.0
Before last move, count for my opponent's worlds showing "x-3", no top of stack visible.
End of game, was showing "x-4", but actual count was 0.
Before last move, count for my opponent's worlds showing "x-3", no top of stack visible.
End of game, was showing "x-4", but actual count was 0.
21. May 2021 13:58 • RegisBull • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Just to say that I still observe this bug regularly enough.
It's annoying because it's a game where having correct information about what opponents have on the top of their stacks, as well as the size of the stacks, can be vital.
It's annoying because it's a game where having correct information about what opponents have on the top of their stacks, as well as the size of the stacks, can be vital.
26. Jul 2021 4:33 • da_fox • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Two players, one using Chrome v91.0, one using Firefox, (more recent version unknown specific)
When Player 1 Abandons multiple tiles then reselects multiple tiles (we abandoned 2 then selected 3) the count of tiles on Players 2 screen became incorrect.
This may have happened after an initial Abandon of a single tile.
Basically, Player 1 Abandoned a single tile, both players finished turn.
Next turn Player 1 Abandoned two tiles. both player finished turn.
Next turn both players did not 'Explore' during that turn it was noticed that the count of tiles was incorrect for Player 2.
Game #189806304
When Player 1 Abandons multiple tiles then reselects multiple tiles (we abandoned 2 then selected 3) the count of tiles on Players 2 screen became incorrect.
This may have happened after an initial Abandon of a single tile.
Basically, Player 1 Abandoned a single tile, both players finished turn.
Next turn Player 1 Abandoned two tiles. both player finished turn.
Next turn both players did not 'Explore' during that turn it was noticed that the count of tiles was incorrect for Player 2.
Game #189806304
31. Aug 2021 14:46 • Tao Tao Roa Room • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Similar problem I see on most or every game. Using firefox.
I, this game, my opponents piles said x1 and x-1, even though they were actually both zero (0).
F5 did solve the problem.
I, this game, my opponents piles said x1 and x-1, even though they were actually both zero (0).
F5 did solve the problem.
16. Jan 2023 17:01 • bananasplay • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I love how BGA continues resolutely ignores all the bugs in this game... the admin can't even be bothered to acknowledge them, much less fix them–and this is how they handle a "Premium" game?
Kudos to HedgieWedgie for providing highly detailed info on the bug, though... somehow it makes the lack of admin attention all the more appalling.
Kudos to HedgieWedgie for providing highly detailed info on the bug, though... somehow it makes the lack of admin attention all the more appalling.
6. Mar 2023 21:03 • lukeg • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
The tile counters are always wrong for my opponents and there's usually a point in the game in which I cannot even see what tiles the opponent has out, which affects my ability to strategize. Please please please please fix this. It's been like this for years.
9. Jan 2024 3:23 • morvita • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I'm seeing this bug in nearly every Roll For the Galaxy game I play. Seems to happen when players abandon tiles during the scouting action.
imgur.com/a/ZP439te
imgur.com/a/ZP439te
13. Feb 2024 5:54 • jujubee • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Same, same, same. Every single game I have to refresh regularly to see other players' cards.
C'mon, y'all. This poor game has several bugs and it's languishing. I know you are throwing energy into other games, but please tend to the ones that us loyal BGA subscribers play. Thanks.
C'mon, y'all. This poor game has several bugs and it's languishing. I know you are throwing energy into other games, but please tend to the ones that us loyal BGA subscribers play. Thanks.
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
