All reports
stirfryeighteen_displayed reports
#7849: "There are more than 18cards appear in the game"
notabug: This is not a bug
1
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
There are more than 18cards in the game
plus the discarded cards seem to be immediately draw• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
throughout the whole game• What is your browser?
Mozilla v5
Report history
7. Jul 2017 17:16 •
DrKarotte • More information is requested by developers to reproduce this bug:
7. Jul 2017 23:37 • I have gone through the whole replay an cannot detect anything wrong with the amount of cards.
weingwoman • More information is requested by developers to reproduce this bug:
8. Jul 2017 9:33 • oh.. sorry.. I think I add the number of cards on my hand twice, there should be no bug.. sorry!
weingwoman • More information is requested by developers to reproduce this bug:
8. Jul 2017 9:39 • but may I also ask if the game rule is
if I call a bluff and I am caught, I could cook in the round, but not discard anymore, and I do not draw a new card right before round ends
and
If I am not associated with any bluffs, I draw a card in the beginning and end of my turn (regardless of number of cards in my hands, even much greater than 3? do I always draw 1 and discard to 3?)
thanks!
if I call a bluff and I am caught, I could cook in the round, but not discard anymore, and I do not draw a new card right before round ends
and
If I am not associated with any bluffs, I draw a card in the beginning and end of my turn (regardless of number of cards in my hands, even much greater than 3? do I always draw 1 and discard to 3?)
thanks!
DrKarotte • This is not a bug:
8. Jul 2017 12:19 • If you are cought, you must not draw any card in this turn, which means:
1) You could discard again in theory, if the bluff was on the first discard, but as you won't draw any card, this is useless and thus disabled ;-)
2) No card drawn after cooking.
You draw after cooking (unless you have been caught bluffing, see above) and at the beginning of your turn, regardless the amount of cards on hand. The hand max at the end of the turn is 3 in every case. If you don't cook, you won't draw but have to reduce to 3.
1) You could discard again in theory, if the bluff was on the first discard, but as you won't draw any card, this is useless and thus disabled ;-)
2) No card drawn after cooking.
You draw after cooking (unless you have been caught bluffing, see above) and at the beginning of your turn, regardless the amount of cards on hand. The hand max at the end of the turn is 3 in every case. If you don't cook, you won't draw but have to reduce to 3.
weingwoman • This is not a bug:
8. Jul 2017 13:51 • Ok I understand now :D
but it often happen that I could discard a protein but in my first move I discard 2 different cards to bluff (for example I have a few points left from 50), but then I am not allowed to bluff again after caught..
but it often happen that I could discard a protein but in my first move I discard 2 different cards to bluff (for example I have a few points left from 50), but then I am not allowed to bluff again after caught..
weingwoman • This is not a bug:
8. Jul 2017 13:55 • for example I have 40points, with noodles, noodles, soy sauce and pork on my hand, and I first discard noodles and soy sauce to look for a mushroom and I am caught
DrKarotte • This is not a bug:
9. Jul 2017 12:07 • These are general questions concerning game rules and playing strategy. Perhaps you better open a thread in the Game forum, so that all players can discuss that? :-)
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.