All reports
beyondthesun_displayed reports
#42658: "Score Display is wrong"
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Display bug: some game information displayed was wrong (with no important consequence on the game)
Detailed description
• Please describe the display issue. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
at the end of the game, the score was 47/45/42 yet when the game ended the player with 42 points suddenly had 45 points displayed instead
• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v91
Report history
15. Jun 2021 21:54 • spielmaster • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table #180481880
Move #138
Progression 98%
Same bug in this game. Score showed 66 to 58. But then 58 on "final result" turned into 68 and was declared winner.
Move #138
Progression 98%
Same bug in this game. Score showed 66 to 58. But then 58 on "final result" turned into 68 and was declared winner.
5. Jul 2021 18:33 • Charloque • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
the score displayed ont the left side is not the same as the score in the final results section :
snipboard.io/sAojLB.jpg
snipboard.io/sAojLB.jpg
22. Aug 2021 23:47 • Supergravity • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Game 196173617 which ended at move 140. After end scoring, Red score shown to red player, and displayed to red player on the "results" page, was 60, but Red was declared the winner. Upon refeshing (F5) both the score and the results page had the correct score (73).
Blue score did not change after the refresh (62) so I assume it was correct.
It is perhaps relevant that on the final round (Red playing last) both players researched a level-4 technology. However, the discrepancy in the displayed Red score (13 points) was not the same as the bonus for the technology researched (8 points).
Blue score did not change after the refresh (62) so I assume it was correct.
It is perhaps relevant that on the final round (Red playing last) both players researched a level-4 technology. However, the discrepancy in the displayed Red score (13 points) was not the same as the bonus for the technology researched (8 points).
22. Aug 2021 23:59 • Supergravity • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I have a screen shot in gamie 196173617 of the end display before doing refresh, obtained by replaying from jus before Blue got the Transcendence award, but I don't deal with apps that require you to whitelist against ad blocking, so it is not being posted on imgur.
But what I did notice (BIG CLUE) is that during the scoring, the score number shown for red suddenly dropped from 64 to 51 points. That is exactly the 13 point discrepancy.
The screenshot shows the following, from top to bottom on the right:
<icon>SUPERGRAVITY <Amer flag icon>
60 (*)
But what I did notice (BIG CLUE) is that during the scoring, the score number shown for red suddenly dropped from 64 to 51 points. That is exactly the 13 point discrepancy.
The screenshot shows the following, from top to bottom on the right:
<icon>SUPERGRAVITY <Amer flag icon>
60 (*)
23. Aug 2021 0:05 • Supergravity • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Continuing the screen shot of game 196173617
60 (*) 151
<ore icon> 10 <anorexic person icon> 0
Nishida-OOstergaard Corporation
------------
<icon> BERTRAND_ <Ital flag icon>
62 (*) 118
<ore icon> 4 <anorexic person icon> 0
the Zheng-Yi Brotherhood
Spectators...
The end of the game: SUPERGRAVITY wins.
60 (*) 151
<ore icon> 10 <anorexic person icon> 0
Nishida-OOstergaard Corporation
------------
<icon> BERTRAND_ <Ital flag icon>
62 (*) 118
<ore icon> 4 <anorexic person icon> 0
the Zheng-Yi Brotherhood
Spectators...
The end of the game: SUPERGRAVITY wins.
21. Sep 2021 4:38 • Lowbeer • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
We had a similar issue: two of the scores matched, but sreaberac's score was 56 in the game panel and 68 on the BGA game over screen. The 68 seemed to be correct.
17. Oct 2021 15:48 • Sir_Newton • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
19. Oct 2021 11:16 • Phoxtrot • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
The current situation:
The running score doesn't count everything.
The following is not counted:
* Points gained from IIII (all level 4 techs, including the ones that grant a fixed amount of VPs)
* Points gained from colony bonuses (like Krueger)
* Points gained from locations controlled at game end
* Points gained from Tier 2 Guild Events ( meaning Onu, Speaker for the Colonies and KC-24X, First Android Governor. )
* Those weird points you gain from event card like 1 point for every 3 military power at end of game etc. Confirmed for the following but likely for all of them:
* * Points gained from Monolith Construction
* * Points gained from Interstellar Arms Race
* * ...
I don't know if Points gained from private Technologies are counted or not (there wasn't any in the game I analyzed for discrepancies)
--------------------------
My ideas:
I think that "Points gained from Tier 2 Guild Events" should be included in the running count and something displayed near the player's board to show those points clearly so that we can do a manual count of everyone's points.
I would be for the best if there was a button to open a table that shows the complete score itemized. Akin to what has been done for "New Frontiers".
And the running score could then include everything even the prospective points so that it would get a clear meaning : "what would be my score if the game ended now".
Possibly, there could be a table option to disable the running score completely. This can make sense in a fast real-time game where you don't really have the time to follow exactly where everyone stands.
The running score doesn't count everything.
The following is not counted:
* Points gained from IIII (all level 4 techs, including the ones that grant a fixed amount of VPs)
* Points gained from colony bonuses (like Krueger)
* Points gained from locations controlled at game end
* Points gained from Tier 2 Guild Events ( meaning Onu, Speaker for the Colonies and KC-24X, First Android Governor. )
* Those weird points you gain from event card like 1 point for every 3 military power at end of game etc. Confirmed for the following but likely for all of them:
* * Points gained from Monolith Construction
* * Points gained from Interstellar Arms Race
* * ...
I don't know if Points gained from private Technologies are counted or not (there wasn't any in the game I analyzed for discrepancies)
--------------------------
My ideas:
I think that "Points gained from Tier 2 Guild Events" should be included in the running count and something displayed near the player's board to show those points clearly so that we can do a manual count of everyone's points.
I would be for the best if there was a button to open a table that shows the complete score itemized. Akin to what has been done for "New Frontiers".
And the running score could then include everything even the prospective points so that it would get a clear meaning : "what would be my score if the game ended now".
Possibly, there could be a table option to disable the running score completely. This can make sense in a fast real-time game where you don't really have the time to follow exactly where everyone stands.
12. Nov 2021 3:56 • ritla • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table #215834770
Move #141
Progression 96%
The points displayed shows
ritla 57
calraven 58
A game replay repeated this scoring.
As a premium member, in the detail scoring I see that ritla had 60 points.
Table #215834770
Move #141
Progression 96%
The points displayed shows
ritla 57
calraven 58
A game replay repeated this scoring.
As a premium member, in the detail scoring I see that ritla had 60 points.
13. Jan 2023 23:03 • Rychlik • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
imgur.com/a/xxpCMYP
Zopakovat Beyond the Sun #336077531
Same problem. Score in the Game results is different than in the right panel. Correct is the Game result I think.
Zopakovat Beyond the Sun #336077531
Same problem. Score in the Game results is different than in the right panel. Correct is the Game result I think.
27. Jun 2023 1:14 • Soqquadro • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
#391037117
During endgame, as final scoring is calculated, 6 points are detracted from a player score, apparently when the effect of a Lvl4 technology (Giga-corporations) is taken into account.
Final score for this player is shown as 42 (incorrect) on game display or 54 (correct) in final score window. Contribution of 6 (positive!) points is recorded correctly in game log.
During endgame, as final scoring is calculated, 6 points are detracted from a player score, apparently when the effect of a Lvl4 technology (Giga-corporations) is taken into account.
Final score for this player is shown as 42 (incorrect) on game display or 54 (correct) in final score window. Contribution of 6 (positive!) points is recorded correctly in game log.
13. Mar 2024 19:10 • cashanek • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
at the end of the game, the score was 41/47/36 at right top panel of score/source, however in final results table it was 51/47/36
29. Jun 2024 15:18 • RetroRobert • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Roughly same issue. At end of game, I was watching final score calculation... I knew I was winning by a margin of about 20 points. Was watching the score in the upper right increment, but then suddenly it started counting backwards. It eventually ended on 46 to my opponents 42. However the score displayed in the "final score" page correctly showed 62 to 42.
Link to screenshot: imgur.com/a/P2rY1g5
I think I know where it happened... looking through the logs, I see the "Final Round is Over" entry, and I can count through my score as it gets to 54 points with two items left in the log. The next one was a substitution of a Star control disk with a Food control disk as a result of the Giga Corporations Tech. The next and last remaining entry was 8 points for that. Those 8 points counted *backwards* on the upper right score tracker (taking me from 54 down to 46) while the end of game page correctly counted it forwards from 54 to 62,
Robert
Link to screenshot: imgur.com/a/P2rY1g5
I think I know where it happened... looking through the logs, I see the "Final Round is Over" entry, and I can count through my score as it gets to 54 points with two items left in the log. The next one was a substitution of a Star control disk with a Food control disk as a result of the Giga Corporations Tech. The next and last remaining entry was 8 points for that. Those 8 points counted *backwards* on the upper right score tracker (taking me from 54 down to 46) while the end of game page correctly counted it forwards from 54 to 62,
Robert
19. Aug 2024 1:42 • Ranger2718 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Incorrect score shown in player boxes. 52 to 56, when actual score is 52 to 67
boardgamearena.com/5/beyondthesun?table=551629311
F5 did resolve the problem
boardgamearena.com/5/beyondthesun?table=551629311
F5 did resolve the problem
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
