Report • Board Game Arena

All reports

carcassonne_displayed reports

#33211: "Incorrect scoring with a circle road. Missing one point"

notupdated: This report has been closed automatically because there was no vote/comment on it for a long time

What is this report about?

carcassonne #141421534

What happened ? Please select from below

Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected

What happened ? Please select from below

Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected

Please check if there is already a report on the same subject

If yes, please VOTE for this report. Reports with the most votes are taken care of in PRIORITY!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Detailed description

Report history

1. Feb 2021 22:14 • MikeFR78 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

There is a four cards circular road which must count for twice at the junction. So in my case 5 points instead of 4.

8. Feb 2022 12:16 • Sourisdudesert • This report has been closed automatically because there was no vote/comment on it for a long time:

Report closed automatically because it has not been upvoted or commented for a while.

Your bug has probably been fixed already, or was linked to a temporary failure of BGA service.

In any case, when filling a bug report, make sure to have an explicit title linked to the incident (ex: with error message), so other players can recognize it and vote for it.

2. Dec 2022 19:33 • PitbullBori • This report has been closed automatically because there was no vote/comment on it for a long time:

I have the same issue and I just wanted to report this bug and found that the topic was already raised in this note.
This is a general problem in the counting logic. When a circle road is formed, the starting and ending sections are on the same tile - the starting section and the ending section should be worth 1 point each, so the tile itself should be worth 2 points (because it contains two sections of the road). Unfortunately, this is never calculated the right way. I see this every time when such a circle road is placed on the table.

Latest example: Table #321557612, moves 90-93.
imgur.com/a/1yjXtEW

2. Dec 2022 20:02 • PitbullBori • This report has been closed automatically because there was no vote/comment on it for a long time:

Is it possible to re-open the report? Or should I create a new one to collect more likes. Thank you.

3. Dec 2022 00:32 • CyberMatt • This report has been closed automatically because there was no vote/comment on it for a long time:

This is not a bug, but rather a misunderstanding of the rules of Carcassonne.
I was curious about whether this complaint was correct, so I checked my copy of the Carcassonne rules and it states "The player who has a thief on a completed road score one point for each tile in the complete road (count the number of tiles; separate segments on a tile count just once)."
So, a circle road counts for 4 points because it is comprised of 4 land tiles, not 5 points for 5 visual road segments.

Add something to this report

Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:

Another table ID / move ID
Did F5 solve the problem?
Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.

LB_CANCEL Update report

#33211: "Incorrect scoring with a circle road. Missing one point"

What is this report about?

What happened ? Please select from below

What happened ? Please select from below

Please check if there is already a report on the same subject

Detailed description

Report history

Add something to this report

Change report status to:

LB_HELP

Contribute

Navigate

Follow us