All reports
tzolkin_displayed reports
#13606: "Problem with annulation"
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
I annul my round 23/27 and so the play begin at round 22, and so two time• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
190• What is your browser?
Mozilla v5
Report history
28. Sep 2019 19:14 • Pinovitch • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I annul my round 23/27 and so the play begin at round 22, and so two time
7. Oct 2019 19:05 • fred_eli • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I think I got something similar... The other player advanced the calendar 2 days, just before lunch-time (festin in French)
I first picked a worker for the double building... and noticed I needed to convert on the market first. So instead of building, I clicked "pass" and then when I canceled my turn... it canceled the 2 days forward of the other player !
We're now back at turn #75 in game boardgamearena.com/1/tzolkin?table=58328544
Hope it helps
I first picked a worker for the double building... and noticed I needed to convert on the market first. So instead of building, I clicked "pass" and then when I canceled my turn... it canceled the 2 days forward of the other player !
We're now back at turn #75 in game boardgamearena.com/1/tzolkin?table=58328544
Hope it helps
23. Jan 2020 8:53 • Olene • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Même problème. L'annulation de l'action a fait reculer la roue d'un cran. La roue était sur un jour de festin, après l'annulation elle est sur le cran précédent. Partie #63272313, le 23/01/2020 9H06, jour 6/27. Ce n'est pas la première fois que cela se produit sur une de mes parties.
Canceling my round moves the wheel back one step. boardgamearena.com/1/tzolkin?table=63272313
Canceling my round moves the wheel back one step. boardgamearena.com/1/tzolkin?table=63272313
30. Mar 2020 16:50 • BanBan • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Same issue here twice in the following game:
boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=69657906
During moves 360/361
During moves 39/40
In fact, I undo only two times during the game and it seems that it happen (2x2) four times in the historics.
I think that's occuring only when player A take the first player, he choose to turn the wheel 1 or 2, then player A plays his next turn as first player, then he wants to undo and the bug is occuring... (his two last actions are undo instead of the last one...)
boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=69657906
During moves 360/361
During moves 39/40
In fact, I undo only two times during the game and it seems that it happen (2x2) four times in the historics.
I think that's occuring only when player A take the first player, he choose to turn the wheel 1 or 2, then player A plays his next turn as first player, then he wants to undo and the bug is occuring... (his two last actions are undo instead of the last one...)
4. May 2020 18:03 • totre63 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
De mon côté j'ai rencontré le même problème dans une partie à 2 joueurs :
- Je place un ouvrier sur l'action "1er joueur" alors que je suis déjà le premier joueur (par ex : au tour 10) avec la possibilité d'avancer de 1 ou 2 tours : c'est donc l'adversaire qui reprend la main (en avançant de 2 tours on passe au tour 12 dans l'exemple)
- L'adversaire commence et annule son action (pendant le tour 12) : il redémarre à ses actions du tour précédent (dans l'exemple son tour 10)
Le bug semble connu --> je viens de jouer contre un certain "Il Panda" qui a profité de ce bug 2 fois dans la partie pour modifier ses actions puisque j'avais choisi d'avancer de 2 tours et que ça ne l'arrangeait pas.
Mon avis sur le problème : la programmation ne considère pas que le choix d'avancer de 1 ou 2 tour est une action d'un joueur donc lorsque l’adversaire annule sont coup il revient au début de son coup global
- Je place un ouvrier sur l'action "1er joueur" alors que je suis déjà le premier joueur (par ex : au tour 10) avec la possibilité d'avancer de 1 ou 2 tours : c'est donc l'adversaire qui reprend la main (en avançant de 2 tours on passe au tour 12 dans l'exemple)
- L'adversaire commence et annule son action (pendant le tour 12) : il redémarre à ses actions du tour précédent (dans l'exemple son tour 10)
Le bug semble connu --> je viens de jouer contre un certain "Il Panda" qui a profité de ce bug 2 fois dans la partie pour modifier ses actions puisque j'avais choisi d'avancer de 2 tours et que ça ne l'arrangeait pas.
Mon avis sur le problème : la programmation ne considère pas que le choix d'avancer de 1 ou 2 tour est une action d'un joueur donc lorsque l’adversaire annule sont coup il revient au début de son coup global
27. Jun 2020 1:56 • aginis • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
So the problem is that if you were last on a turn and on the next turn you are first they get treated as the same turn.
This affects play in two ways:
1. you don't get a time increment at the start of your second turn.
2. If you undo your turn the board resets to the beginning of your first move instead of the second, this is a problem because you can change your mind about advancing calendar twice or change your move based on new buildings that come out (either because you built something that turn or because the second half of the game replaces the buildings) not to mention that the time problem only gets worse if you have to replay two moves instead of one.
This affects play in two ways:
1. you don't get a time increment at the start of your second turn.
2. If you undo your turn the board resets to the beginning of your first move instead of the second, this is a problem because you can change your mind about advancing calendar twice or change your move based on new buildings that come out (either because you built something that turn or because the second half of the game replaces the buildings) not to mention that the time problem only gets worse if you have to replay two moves instead of one.
27. Jun 2020 2:00 • aginis • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
also in case it wasn't clear this can happen two ways, either you are last and take the first player spot or in a two player game you are last and your opponent takes the first player spot, in both cases the bug reproduces consistently.
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
