All reports
scythe_displayed reports
#133895: "Game auto-selected my power and combat cards at 0 for combat"
fixed: Bug has been fixed
34
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
The part where I get to choose how much power and how many combat cards I get to play was completely skipped.• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
It was at 10:42 PM on August 12.• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v127
Report history
14. Aug 2024 4:36 • Jorlbs • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I am using arc browser on my computer and on my phone. It's possible that I had a connection to the game through both locations I suppose. But both devices were asleep when it happened and so was I.
16. Aug 2024 19:58 • Shivaware • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
It's possible that the trigger for this issue is when someone submits their combat dial choices, then changes their mind and submits new combat dial choices. This seems to cause the combat to be evaluated with the other player having 0 power submitted.
I'm currently in game 548388051. At move 318, my opponent triggered combat with me, but it first asked me if I wanted to use Saxony's Disarm ability. By the time I moved, my opponent was offline. I submitted my power dial settings, then later reconsidered and submitted lower power dial settings. The combat immediately resolved, even though my opponent was still offline.
I'm also in game 548336128, and in that case my opponent triggered a combat with me at move 266. I was offline at the time, and 14 minutes later the combat resolved without my input. I have not asked my opponent if they resubmitted their power dial choices.
I'm currently in game 548388051. At move 318, my opponent triggered combat with me, but it first asked me if I wanted to use Saxony's Disarm ability. By the time I moved, my opponent was offline. I submitted my power dial settings, then later reconsidered and submitted lower power dial settings. The combat immediately resolved, even though my opponent was still offline.
I'm also in game 548336128, and in that case my opponent triggered a combat with me at move 266. I was offline at the time, and 14 minutes later the combat resolved without my input. I have not asked my opponent if they resubmitted their power dial choices.
20. Aug 2024 0:11 • Direw0lf2 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I can confirm what Shivaware is saying about this. Locking in your power, then changing it, then locking it in again, triggers the end of the combat with the other player not having a chance to input anything
24. Aug 2024 8:17 • luisnoelf • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I also experienced this from the attackers side. This is the game. boardgamearena.com/1/scythe?table=551022319. I cannot see a way to identify the move ID but it was the first combat between Rusviet and Saxony around Move #349. As described before, I set up power level and cards, then changed my mind, that triggered the end of the combat with Rusviet having no chance to use the power dial.
24. Aug 2024 21:50 • _Galathras • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
551210037
We are playing the game in beta mode and the combats are not working properly. The attacker always wins and the defender has no option to defend.
If it helps.
We are playing the game in beta mode and the combats are not working properly. The attacker always wins and the defender has no option to defend.
If it helps.
28. Aug 2024 19:56 • Balkanlii • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Just happened to me at least 2 times. I thought it was a coincidence but now I understand what happened. After submitting your power and cards for battle, if you want to change what you have selected and do a resubmit, it makes you the winner of the battle immediately saying your opponent has used 0 power and 0 cards.
3. Sep 2024 16:37 • Mahrnol • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
It was in a turn based match, as a defender i hadn't the option to combat.
If it matters I'm using bga app on huawei p20 lite
If it matters I'm using bga app on huawei p20 lite
10. Sep 2024 11:21 • stracht • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I see this happening all the time in turn based matches.
I was attacked in the factory and the attacker immediately won. (The attacker asked if he had won against me instantly because I didn't even take the turn. and yes. I had no option to select power or CC.
When I opened up the game I could only retreat
My latest example:
Table #560056744
Move #280
I was attacked in the factory and the attacker immediately won. (The attacker asked if he had won against me instantly because I didn't even take the turn. and yes. I had no option to select power or CC.
When I opened up the game I could only retreat
My latest example:
Table #560056744
Move #280
11. Sep 2024 11:12 • Peqii • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
This also happened for me in table #557229870 by
1. As an attacker, I choose my power and cards
2. I realized I made a mistake and I reloaded whole web page
3. I submitted new values -> Combat automatically resolved itself
1. As an attacker, I choose my power and cards
2. I realized I made a mistake and I reloaded whole web page
3. I submitted new values -> Combat automatically resolved itself
16. Sep 2024 22:20 • SegelJunge • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table - 561511536 / Turn 558
I was attacking and I had to wait for my opponent to select artillery. When I rejoined the table the game select just zero and no card for my attack.
I was attacking and I had to wait for my opponent to select artillery. When I rejoined the table the game select just zero and no card for my attack.
18. Sep 2024 3:25 • MrGrossom • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table #558174816 additional example
This is a turn-based table. I was not notified of my option to play. When I returned, the log said I had committed 0 power and chosen not to play a card.
This is a turn-based table. I was not notified of my option to play. When I returned, the log said I had committed 0 power and chosen not to play a card.
18. Sep 2024 5:02 • truebroyeti • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I submitted two 3 power cards in my combat and then had second thoughts and tried to click on the power button on the off chance I could change what I submitted and it let me change what cards and power I threw. Right after I did that it resolved the combat and I thought I had switched the power just in time. However, after my opponents next turn he said he did not see that the combat had taken place.
7. Oct 2024 15:23 • Samiamiamiam • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I've had this happen to me twice now. The first time, an opponant attacked me when I was offline in two different locations in the same move. When I was notified it was my turn and opened the game, my move was only to determine where I would retreat to (home base or a lake). For both battles, the game log said I chose 0 power and 0 combat cards.
It just happened to me again in Table #571824676 around 64% progression (shortly before hand #301). I was the attacker this time. I had my character and one mech. I selected two combat cards, but before I could select power on the wheel the battle card window closed and the game said I chose 0 power and 0 combat cards and I lost.
It just happened to me again in Table #571824676 around 64% progression (shortly before hand #301). I was the attacker this time. I had my character and one mech. I selected two combat cards, but before I could select power on the wheel the battle card window closed and the game said I chose 0 power and 0 combat cards and I lost.
14. Oct 2024 17:35 • ddemoss • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
This happened to me as well.
21. Oct 2024 11:47 • Plotinus3 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Table 574465389, It happened to me twice in this game, once as defender, once as attacker.
25. Oct 2024 13:02 • Mororats • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
boardgamearena.com/10/scythe?table=572054765
I stop playing juste After the bug. Lose thé fight can't put a card.
I stop playing juste After the bug. Lose thé fight can't put a card.
1. Nov 2024 17:57 • Melarnos • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
boardgamearena.com/6/scythe?table=579595607
Exact same issue here.
I play a turn-based game. When my turn came I saw that a combat had happened but I hadn't even been prompted to play anything, and I lost the combat. That's a little bit of a HUGE bug for a game like Scythe :D
imgur.com/a/oCITkO7
Exact same issue here.
I play a turn-based game. When my turn came I saw that a combat had happened but I hadn't even been prompted to play anything, and I lost the combat. That's a little bit of a HUGE bug for a game like Scythe :D
imgur.com/a/oCITkO7
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
