All reports
wingspan_displayed reports
#124525: "Eggs miscalculated in end game scoring"
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
According to the rules, I'm supposed to get 1 point per egg on my mat. I have 17 both visually present on the mat and mentioned in the player information. But when it comes to end game scoring, only 16 are counted• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
At the end of the game, move #171• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v125
Report history
21. May 2024 16:28 • Senseless Thinker • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
27. Aug 2024 2:32 • Neagle • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
In game 554579916. In third round scoring after move#109. Eggs in hollows has not calculated properly.
It seems it did not count eggs on ash-throated flycatcher on neagles card. Count should be 7, not 3.
Insult to injury as this game ended in tie in tournament and other player randomly elevated to next round when they actually should have lost.
It seems it did not count eggs on ash-throated flycatcher on neagles card. Count should be 7, not 3.
Insult to injury as this game ended in tie in tournament and other player randomly elevated to next round when they actually should have lost.
28. Aug 2024 14:21 • Neagle • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Happened again in round 2 scori g this time in 555537809 about move 105 . For birds with hollow/cavity nests did not count eggs correctly. This time on Carina sparrow I think? Only similarity with last time ash throated flycatcher is that they are both white cards no brown powers. I noted in game it was not counting these 4 eggs clearly on the cavity nest bird.
I am surprised at how mature this game is and so many plays this is not being noticed more often? Perhaps speed of game or too lazy to report, but getting the scoring right is pretty important, games results will be impacted. In this game I had to lay another round of eggs to get bonus.
I am surprised at how mature this game is and so many plays this is not being noticed more often? Perhaps speed of game or too lazy to report, but getting the scoring right is pretty important, games results will be impacted. In this game I had to lay another round of eggs to get bonus.
7. Sep 2024 1:16 • Neagle • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Please ignore my two report histories for this. It was my misunderstanding of the card. Sorry for my foolishness. Counts birds with eggs not counting eggs.
27. Oct 2024 13:19 • Fortuna • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
Same for my game: I had room for 25 eggs and in the last round I filled up all the nests with the maximum amount of eggs. It says 24/25 below my name, eventhough all places are filled and I have 25 eggs on my player mat. In the 'final situation' log it also just counts 24 eggs, this could effect losing/winning!
Table 581008555.
Table 581008555.
26. Feb 2025 15:33 • oddbgo • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
I having egg related problem too, but mine relate to end of ground goal contribution.
Just look at these image and will understand that player Your name K, somehow make his Great Egret’s egg contribute toward end of round goal, despite wrong egg shape.
#14egg on right shape, but 1 on wrong shape, yet the game count it to be 15egg contributed to end of round, which is 14+1=15, which is equal to mine. (and should not happen)
and my board player oddbgo, being normal, having 15 egg which all contributed to end of round goal.
imgur.com/a/MvXThaq
Just look at these image and will understand that player Your name K, somehow make his Great Egret’s egg contribute toward end of round goal, despite wrong egg shape.
#14egg on right shape, but 1 on wrong shape, yet the game count it to be 15egg contributed to end of round, which is 14+1=15, which is equal to mine. (and should not happen)
and my board player oddbgo, being normal, having 15 egg which all contributed to end of round goal.
imgur.com/a/MvXThaq
26. Feb 2025 15:37 • oddbgo • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:
#635931907
having egg related problem too, but mine relate to end of ground goal contribution.
Just look at these image and will understand that player Your name K, somehow make his Great Egret’s egg contribute toward end of round goal, despite wrong egg shape.
#14egg on right shape, but 1 on wrong shape, yet the game count it to be 15egg contributed to end of round, which is 14+1=15, which is equal to mine. (and should not happen)
and my board player oddbgo, being normal, having 15 egg which all contributed to end of round goal.
imgur.com/a/MvXThaq
having egg related problem too, but mine relate to end of ground goal contribution.
Just look at these image and will understand that player Your name K, somehow make his Great Egret’s egg contribute toward end of round goal, despite wrong egg shape.
#14egg on right shape, but 1 on wrong shape, yet the game count it to be 15egg contributed to end of round, which is 14+1=15, which is equal to mine. (and should not happen)
and my board player oddbgo, being normal, having 15 egg which all contributed to end of round goal.
imgur.com/a/MvXThaq
Add something to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
